How to solve the Red Dead Redemption 2 Killer Clue mystery (2024)

FAQs

Where is the final killer clue in rdr2? ›

The third and final Killer Clue Piece location is south of Rhodes. If you've yet to reach there in the story (you have to visit in Chapter 3) then don't worry, you can use fast travel and use a train to get there at any point from the start of Chapter 2 onwards.

Investigate the serial killer's hideout, and in the very back there'll be a knife you can inspect. Doing so will trigger a cutscene in which the serial killer will attack you. He's not too hard to fight off, and you can hogtie him and take him back to the sheriff's office in Valentine to collect your reward.

You can start the hunt for the killer at any time once you've completed chapter one and are free to explore the open world. You can also visit the locations in any order you wish but we're starting just south of Valentine, the first town you'll visit in the game.

Subsequently, the player either takes her to the town's sheriff directly or tells him to visit the scene of the murder. Either way, the player is rewarded $12 and the prostitute is incarcerated. With this choice, the protagonist gains Honor. A few days thereafter, she is publicly hanged on the gallows in Valentine.

Arthur's Grave – Can be visited as John Marston after Arthur Morgan's death, located on top of the mountain to the northeast of Bacchus bridge. Whether players had high or low honor as Arthur Morgan will impact the epitaph, with high honor also spawning an eagle and low honor spawning a coyote.

No matter what you do, Arthur Morgan dies. There's currently no secret ending where he somewhat survives, fading into the mists of time under a new name. As noted in the endings above, he either dies from his tuberculosis, a bullet to the head, or a knife in the back.

Once that's over and done with, stow the Stranger on the back of your horse and head into town to turn him in. In the subsequent scene, you have a choice - kill the serial killer, or let the Sheriff kill him. Do the dirty work yourself and you'll be rewarded with $20.

The Sheriff is shaken but grateful, and rewards the player with $20. If the player decides not to intervene: Malloy eventually manages to force Lowry Jr. off and shoots him in the chest when he's on the floor next to him. Angry that the player did not assist him, Malloy doesn't pay them and asks them to get out.

Edmund Lowry Jr. is a minor antagonist in the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption 2, and the main antagonist of the "American Dreams" side-quest involving the pursuit and capture of a gruesome serial killer.

Lucky's Cabin is a location in The Heartlands, NH near Valentine. It's a ruined building with not much to find in the rubble, but there are good resources nearby.

How do I start the quest getting a clue? ›

As soon as you're ready to begin the newly-acquired Getting A Clue quest, open your Pip-Boy map and fast travel to Diamond City Market. Your first task is to rendezvous with Nick Valentine and see what he knows about your missing son.

A serial killer (also called a serial murderer) is a person who murders three or more people, with the killings taking place over a significant period of time in separate events.

Rob Banks and Trains and People, Carefully

Robberies are hard to pull off, but also come with some excellent rewards if you're successful. Just remember to plan an escape route in advance and wear a mask to ensure that your reputation doesn't take too much of a hit.

To facilitate this mechanic, players have a lasso they can use to hogtie NPCs. However, as with the game's combat mechanics, this system applies to most NPCs in the game, and the player will become wanted for kidnapping if they are caught hogtying innocent NPCs.

A secret bonus ending is available with 100% completion, showcasing John visiting Arthur's grave in a touching conclusion to the Western saga. To unlock the bonus ending, players must complete extensive tasks, including main missions, collectibles, challenges, and maxing out John's stats.

Don't worry, the final chapter of this mission won't open up until later in Chapter 4. Return to the saloon in Valentine and speak to the bartender, who will send you to Saint Denis and the Grand Korrigan riverboat. Speak to Calloway to reveal the final gunslinger.

Arthur Morgan Grave

Arthur Morgan's grave can be found to the northeast of Bacchus Station, and east of the grave of Eagle Flies. If you finished the game with a high Honor rating, Arthur's grave will be adorned with flowers.

Nigel's frantic search for his friend Gavin in Red Dead Redemption 2 remains unsolvable after 8 years of hunting.